Finding the right MTF eyeliner can make all the difference when you’re learning how to feminize your features with makeup. Whether you’re just starting out or experimenting with new looks, eyeliner is one of the fastest ways to reshape your eyes, soften your face, and express the version of yourself you actually want to see in the mirror.
The problem? Most eyeliner advice isn’t made with transfeminine faces in mind. That’s why I put together this list: to highlight MTF eyeliner products that actually work—for beginners, for different techniques, and for real-life wear. Some I’ve used myself. Others I’ve researched to death before deciding if they belonged in my routine.
Best Beginner MTF Eyeliner for Trans Women
If I had to pick just one MTF eyeliner to recommend, this is it. It was my first eyeliner, and honestly? I still use it. I own it in black, brown, and charcoal, and all three shades have their place. But if you’re new to eyeliner or trying to soften your features, go for brown or charcoal. They’re way less harsh than black and give a softer, more feminine impression—especially in natural light.
The twist-up design means no sharpening, and the texture makes it glide on easily—even with shaky hands. It’s ideal for gently defining the lash line, adding structure without making your eyes look smaller or too bold. And it’s forgiving enough to smudge or correct as you go.
Long-Lasting MTF Eyeliner for All-Day Wear
Maybelline TattooStudio Waterproof Gel Pencil
This MTF eyeliner is what I reach for when I need something that stays put. It’s intense, long-wearing, and holds up even when my eyes water (I live in an high allergen area). It’s especially great for tightlining or waterline work, where most liners fade quickly.
That said, I don’t use it every day. It’s a bit more effort to remove, and it really does require a proper remover. I usually rely on micellar water or an oil-based cleanser to break it down—regular makeup wipes don’t cut it. But for long shifts, hot days, or emotional ones? This one earns its spot.
Best Liquid Eyeliner for Clean Wings
Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner
This is the only high-end MTF eyeliner I’ve tried so far, and I totally get why people swear by it. The felt tip goes on smooth and gives you clean, defined lines without skipping or dragging. It also has dual tips—so you can switch between a finer or thicker line depending on what you’re doing.
I use the Intense Brown shade because it gives just enough definition to lift my eyes and shape them, without looking too stark. It’s especially good if you’re trying to balance eyeliner with softer features or minimal makeup. Great for a subtle wing or lifting the outer corners for a more open, feminine effect.
Smudgable Pencil Eyeliner for Soft Looks
Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Eye Pencil
I haven’t used this one personally—mostly because I’m still a little scared of smudging and smoke-style looks. But this MTF eyeliner shows up a lot in my research. It’s known for gliding on smooth, blending easily, and then setting in place so it doesn’t move.
If you’re into creating softer lash lines, smoky edges, or more diffused effects, this gives you the flexibility to experiment. Smudged eyeliner can be incredibly flattering on transfeminine faces because it softens angles and adds depth without the starkness of a clean line.
Colorful Eyeliner for Bold and Fun Looks
ColourPop BFF Crème Gel Liner (Set)
This one’s for the bold girls—or for anyone who wants to experiment. Again, full disclosure: I haven’t tried this one myself. I usually go for natural looks, but I included this MTF eyeliner option because sometimes we need color. Whether it’s for Pride, cosplay, themed makeup, or just fun, ColourPop’s bright gel liners show up well and stay put.
They come in a ton of shades: teal, lavender, metallic copper, pastel pink. You can use them on your lower lash line or inner corners to add a flash of color without committing to a full eyeshadow look. It’s a playful way to express different sides of yourself.
Natural Feminine MTF Eyeliner for Everyday
Milani Stay Put Waterproof Eyeliner
This is my current favorite. I use it for everyday wear because it gives me that feminine definition I want, without screaming “I’m wearing eyeliner.” It adds structure to my eyes but still looks natural, which is exactly what I’m going for most days.
The shade I use is Café, though I don’t see it offered anymore. Femme Fatale is a good alternative if you want something cooler-toned and soft. Semi-Sweet works if you’re going for a warmer, deeper brown. Either way, this is the kind of MTF eyeliner that supports your look without overpowering it.
Want to Learn Eyeliner Step-by-Step?
If you’re not sure where to begin, or you’ve tried eyeliner and just can’t get it right, I wrote a full Beginners Guide to Eyeliner for you.
It walks through everything—tightlining, flicks, how to actually use different liner types, and what makes eyeliner look feminine instead of heavy. It’s the guide I wish I’d had when I started.
Whether you’re trans, questioning, or just figuring out how to present more femininely, it’s built to help you understand how eyeliner really works—without the fluff.
Final Thoughts on MTF Eyeliner
Finding the right MTF eyeliner isn’t just about the formula. It’s about how it works for your face—your skin type, your eye shape, your goals. Whether you’re trying to lift your eyes, add subtle structure, go glam, or keep it waterproof, there’s something here that fits.
These are the MTF eyeliner products that have either earned a place in my drawer or caught my attention enough to share. But everyone’s face is different. And honestly? I’d love to hear what’s worked for you.
Have you found a liner that holds up all day? One that makes your eyes pop without going over the top? Drop your favorite picks—or horror stories—in the comments.
I’m still learning too. And your recs might help someone else feel just a little more confident staring into that mirror.
0 Comments